The Pros and Cons of a Consumption Tax
Under Roth IRAs, current tax revenues are largely unaffected, but future revenues take the hit because withdrawals are not taxed at all. Assuming that Congress could somehow achieve true fiscal discipline, it could borrow to fund deficits caused today by conventional IRAs and repay the loans with tax revenues from future IRA withdrawals. In the real world, the Roth approach has much more appeal in Washington because it produces greater revenues today. That would be like a 60 percent tax on all of the money that you had saved up over the course of your life.
The sales tax is usually ad valorem, that is, it is calculated by applying a percentage rate to the taxable price of a sale. Although there is a sales tax in the U.S., it is a form of state tax, not a federal tax. In addition, state sales taxes exempt all sorts of spending, such as food, health, and housing. Countries that have implemented the sales tax as a federal consumption tax, tax almost all consumption. A consumption tax is a tax levied on goods and services consumed or purchased.
Understanding a Consumption Tax
Iowa, Kentucky, Georgia, Minnesota, Ohio, Arkansas, North Carolina, Indiana, Idaho, and others have cut or are considering cuts to their income taxes, sometimes accompanied by modifications of their consumption taxes. 1459 proposes the repeal of that state’s graduated income and corporate net worth taxes while introducing a broad-based sales tax on final consumption of goods and services. The consumption tax would exempt business, investment, and other such intermediate purchases.
The estimates also account for taxpayers’ noncompliance with a VAT, which would reduce the revenues raised. Additionally, because certain goods are excluded from the VAT, consumers might substitute untaxed goods for taxed goods. But consumption taxes are usually regressive taxes, meaning the percent of your income that you pay decreases as your income decreases. For example, someone making $100,000 and someone making $25,000 both pay the same dollar amount of sales taxes on a $100 item, but that tax eats up a greater percentage of the person’s income earning $25,000. So if you move the tax from income to consumption, you’re raising the relative burden on low savers, which are low and moderate income households, so almost any revenue neutral shift from the income tax to a consumption tax will be regressive in that manner. There are ways, there are conceptual ways to do it that doesn’t add burdens to low and middle income households, but I don’t think that they would actually happen.
Tariffs are taxes levied by one country on goods or services imported from another country. Tariffs are usually paid on raw materials at the producer level or for finished goods at the distributor level. Tariffs differ from import duties, which are consumption taxes paid by retail consumers for imported finished goods. Consumption taxes were first introduced in the U.S. in the 1800s and have since been an integral part of the tax system. Globally, though, consumption taxes have a stronger presence and are a very popular form of revenue generation for governments. The United States is unusual in that there is no federal consumption tax on goods and services; it is up to state and local entities to set it up.
Local and state governments often impose sales taxes on certain purchases, and you’ll pay the combined amount on every eligible purchase when you buy something in that area. If you’re shopping online, the merchant might collect sales tax if it has a physical presence in your state. The IRA approach, in contrast, confers the benefit of zero taxes only on new saving.
Consumption tax vs. income tax
Similarly, a tax on wages and salaries would be economically equivalent to a consumption tax on workers. In recent years, proposals have been made to replace the federal income tax with a postpaid consumption tax – that is, a federal value added tax (“VAT”), a federal retail sales tax (“RST”), or a federal cash-flow (consumed income) tax. The analysis, however, would be mostly the same if the income tax was compared with the other forms of postpaid consumption taxes. Commentators and analysts have often noted that complete replacement of the federal income tax with a consumption tax regime would cause a substantial downward shifting of the federal tax burden to low and middle income taxpayers. I conclude that within its premises, the income tax does not double-tax investment income. With the tax base as defined by the current income tax system, they find, the top 5 percent of households (those with incomes above $136,263 in 1989 dollars) would have paid 56 percent of all federal income taxes.
- For example, elderly-headed households spend out of accumulated savings and are likely to consume a larger share of their income than nonelderly households.
- Other examples of consumption taxes include VAT taxes, sales taxes, and taxes on imported goods.
- Consumption taxes are usually indirect, such as a sales tax or a value-added tax.
- After accounting for those exclusions, the tax base would encompass approximately 59 percent of household consumption in 2024.
In the United States, the stamp tax, the tax on tea, and whiskey taxes produced revolts, the first two against the British government and the latter against the federal government. In India, an excise tax on salt led to Mohandas Gandhi’s famous Salt March, a major event in the Indian Independence Movement. A simple value-added tax is proportional to consumption but is regressive on income at higher income levels, as consumption tends to fall as a percentage of income as income rises.
Criticisms of Consumption Taxes
A flat and broad-based tax structure limits the potential influence of government and special interest groups. In the long run, this approach should produce greater and more equitable economic growth, realizing efficiency in a way that is mutually beneficial. In addition to being applied to your money at different times, income and consumption taxes also differ in how they affect taxpayers. In other words, the percentage of your income you pay increases as your income increases. Nevertheless, consumption taxes do play a role in raising government funds in the U.S. In the U.S., consumption taxes usually are designed as sales taxes, excise taxes, and taxes on imported goods.
First, those who pay the most in taxes inevitably will get the greatest dollar benefit from tax reductions. Second, the economic benefits from greater saving—more innovation and greater GDP growth—would be distributed to everyone in the form of a faster increase in real incomes, including wages. Instead of moving to a VAT, most consumption tax advocates want to modify the income tax to eliminate taxes on interest, dividends, and capital gains. Achieving that goal can be done directly by cutting taxes on capital income to zero, as President Bush tried to do in the case of dividends. Alternatively, we could achieve the same result indirectly in two other ways.
We follow strict guidelines to ensure that our editorial content is not influenced by advertisers. Our editorial team receives no direct compensation from advertisers, and our content is thoroughly fact-checked to ensure accuracy. So, whether you’re reading an article or a review, you can trust that you’re getting credible and dependable information. Our mission is to provide readers with accurate and unbiased information, and we have editorial standards in place to ensure that happens.
Sales tax deduction: What it is and how to take advantage of it
Sin taxes, are a type of excise tax imposed on items that are considered harmful to society, in an effort to decrease their consumption by increasing their prices. You might have to pay the VAT on qualifying purchases if you’re traveling to a country that has this tax. While we adhere to strict
this post may contain references to tax pros warn small business owners not to try to deduct these 9 expenses products from our partners. The entire health sector doesn’t like them because the deductions for health insurance disappear. Businesses, a lot of businesses don’t like tax reform because they lose deductions for payroll taxes and other things. So you have to gore someone’s ox in tax reform, and any time you do that they’re not going to like it.
Moving to a complete consumption tax system for the individual tax code would entail little more than allowing universal, unlimited IRAs for everyone and doing away with penalties for early withdrawals. Individuals could continue with the IRAs and 401(k)s they currently have or roll them over into the new plans. Consumption taxes, in theory, would encourage saving and investment, whereas income taxation discourages this behavior because it taxes both consumption and savings.
A homeowner could choose to rent the home to others in exchange for money, but instead chooses to live in the home. Therefore, the homeowner is also consuming housing by not permitting renters to pay for and occupy the home. The amount of money that the homeowner could receive in rent is the imputed rental value of the home.
The higher price includes the consumption tax, which is collected by the vendor and remitted to the appropriate federal, state, or local government. Consumption taxes are often levied at different rates on different commodities according to perceptions of whether a commodity is considered a necessity (such as food) or a luxury (such as jewelry). Consumption taxes can take the form of sales taxes, tariffs, excise, and other taxes on consumed goods and services. Along with decrease in purchasing power, taxes also decrease the relative value of work in relation to leisure time. If a tax is implemented on consumption, the value of spending an hour at work decreases in relation to different activities because the tax decreases the actual amount of goods and services an individual can purchase for a given level of work.
- The cost of production would be reduced, disincentivizing cost-cutting at the expense of workers and potentially lowering prices.
- Because those investments would not be taxed, a cash flow tax on businesses would be economically equivalent to a consumption tax on their incomes.
- Or, as economists Alvin Rabushka and Robert Hall put it, taxing income taxes what people contribute to the economy, while taxing consumption taxes what they take out.
- Economists are confident that this is the value to society because it is a market price that reflects the desires of the various savers and borrowers.
In addition, a broad-based consumption tax can generate a significant amount of revenue at a relatively low tax rate. Compared with income taxes, a consumption tax can produce a more stable stream of revenue, and it is relatively easy to administer. Consumption taxes are taxes that you pay when you purchase goods and services. A consumption tax is designed to tax you when you spend money versus an income tax, which taxes a portion of your wages.